December is usually busy. January often isn’t. Once the holiday parties end, many independent restaurants feel traffic slows down fast.
A restaurant gift card promotion can help with both months. It brings in cash during the holidays and gives guests a reason to visit when things get quiet. But the goal isn’t just to sell more cards. Every card is a future visit, and often an introduction to someone who has never eaten at your restaurant.
This guide covers how to structure the offer, write clear terms, sell restaurant holiday gift cards directly, and turn the people who receive them into regulars.
Why Restaurant Gift Cards Matter Beyond December Sales
A gift card does two jobs. The buyer pays you now, during your busiest season. The visit happens later, often when you need the traffic more.
In Toast’s 2026 restaurant gift card survey of 850 U.S. adults who have bought or received a restaurant gift card, 77% said they had discovered a new restaurant because someone gave them a gift card. The same survey found that 84% use a gift card within three months of getting it. For cards sold in November and December, that window covers January through March.
Treat those numbers as directional, not as a promise for your restaurant. But the pattern makes sense. The buyer already likes you. The recipient may not know you yet.
That makes the redemption visit a first impression someone else paid for. Make it count.
One planning rule: assume every card you sell will be redeemed. Unused balances aren’t a reliable source of profit.
Choose a Bonus Offer That Actually Makes Sense
A restaurant bonus gift card offer gives buyers an extra push. Toast’s survey found that 89% of respondents would be likely to buy a gift card with a bonus offer. Keep yours simple enough to fit on a sign:
Buy a $50 gift card, and receive a $10 promotional reward for a future visit.
That offer has two parts, and they work differently:
- The purchased gift card carries stored value. The guest paid $50, and that $50 follows the card’s own terms.
- The bonus reward is a promotion. You’re giving it away, so it can have its own redemption window and conditions, as long as you state them clearly.
A $10 bonus should never quietly become $60 of stored value on one card.
Why some restaurants make the bonus valid in January and February
The National Restaurant Association suggests making the bonus valid for a limited time, such as the first two months of the year, to drive winter traffic. Your December tables are already full of paying guests. A reward redeemed during a slow week fills a seat that would otherwise sit empty.
There is a trade-off. In Toast’s survey, 48% preferred a bonus they could use right away, while 18% preferred one restricted to later use, such as January. A delayed bonus may sell fewer cards. If December is already packed, the January window makes sense. If you mainly need holiday cash, consider an immediate bonus and promote January visits separately.
Decide your margin before you announce anything
A $10 reward doesn’t cost you $10. It costs what the food and labor behind it cost you. That’s still a real cost, and it’s wasted if rewards mostly go to guests who would have visited anyway.
Pick a bonus ratio you can live with. The association’s examples range from $10 per $50 spent (20%) to $10 per $100 (10%). A minimum check for using the reward, such as $25, protects the margin on that visit. Lock these numbers in before the first sign goes up.
Set Restaurant Gift Card Terms That Customers and Staff Can Understand
Clear terms prevent most gift card problems. Before you promote anything, decide:
- Promotion dates: when the offer starts and ends.
- Minimum purchase: how much a guest must buy to earn the bonus, and whether several smaller cards count.
- Reward amount: the exact value of the bonus reward.
- Redemption window: the first and last day the reward can be used.
- Combining offers: whether the reward works with other discounts or loyalty rewards.
- Per-visit limit: for example, one reward per table or per order.
- Digital and physical cards: whether the same terms apply to both, and where each can be used.
Put the terms in plain language wherever guests see the offer, including the reward itself. Label the bonus clearly as a promotional reward.
Then train your team so everyone gives the same answer. A one-page cheat sheet at the register should cover selling a card, checking a balance, applying a reward, and answering expiration questions.
A note on the rules: Federal rules protect gift-card funds in important ways. For example, money loaded on a store gift card generally can’t expire sooner than five years after it was issued or last loaded. Promotional rewards can follow different terms when those terms are clearly disclosed. State rules may add requirements. Before publishing terms, confirm the details with your payment provider and an appropriate local advisor.
Make Gift Cards Easy to Buy Directly From Your Restaurant
Toast’s survey found that 56% of respondents who buy restaurant gift cards usually buy them directly from the restaurant, in person or online. If someone wants to buy from you, nothing should slow them down.
The best restaurant gift card marketing ideas are simple. Here’s how to sell restaurant gift cards online and in person:
- Add a visible “Gift Cards” link to your website’s main navigation and homepage.
- Promote the offer where guests already see you: email, SMS, social posts, counter signage, table tents, receipts, and online-order confirmation messages.
- Offer a quick digital option and a physical option if your gift card provider supports both. The National Restaurant Association also recommends giving guests that choice.
- Test the buying path on a phone. If it takes more than a few taps, simplify it.
- Contact nearby businesses about bulk holiday orders. Offices, real estate teams, salons, and gyms often need client and staff gifts.
- Give staff a reason to mention it. A small incentive for every few hundred dollars in cards sold keeps gift cards top of mind.
Turn the Gift-Card Recipient Into a Regular
Most promotions stop too early. The card gets redeemed, the balance hits zero, and the recipient never hears from you again. Treat redemption as the start of a relationship.
Decide who the bonus is for. If the buyer keeps it, you’re bringing back someone who already likes you. If the buyer can pass it along with the gift, you’re giving a new guest a reason for a second visit. Both work. Choose on purpose.
Welcome the recipient. At redemption, staff can thank the guest, mention any remaining balance, and invite them to join your loyalty program. A receipt QR code makes sign-up quick.
Give a clear reason to order directly next time. Tell guests what they get for ordering from your website, such as loyalty points or a small reward on their first direct order.
Use a low-cost, high-value reward. A free dessert, drink, or pastry feels generous and costs you less than its menu price.
Follow up in the first few weeks. A thank-you message and a points reminder keep you top of mind while the first visit is fresh. Our guide to restaurant email marketing strategies covers what to send and when.
Measure whether recipients return. Where your system allows it, tag or note orders paid with a gift card. Then check how many of those guests ordered again within 30 to 60 days. That number tells you more than total cards sold.
Make redemption easy. Nobody should wait while a manager figures out how to apply a card. A quick, friendly redemption is what the guest remembers.
For a deeper playbook, see how to turn first-time customers into regulars and how to build customer loyalty programs for restaurants that guests actually use.
Track Whether the Promotion Was Worth It
Card sales alone won’t tell you whether your restaurant gift card promotion worked. Track:
- Number and dollar value of gift cards sold
- Number of bonus rewards issued
- Bonus reward redemption rate
- Average check when a bonus reward is redeemed
- Loyalty signups from gift-card recipients
- First-to-second-order conversion for recipients
- January and February sales are connected to the campaign
Compare January and February with the same weeks last year, not with December. If most rewards went to regulars who would have visited anyway, adjust next year’s offer.
Before You Launch
- Set your bonus ratio and confirm the margin works.
- Write plain-language terms and confirm them with your provider and a local advisor.
- Keep the gift card and bonus reward separate in your system and materials.
- Add a “Gift Cards” link to your website navigation and homepage.
- Test the full purchase and redemption flow on a phone, for both digital and physical cards.
- Train every shift on selling cards, checking balances, and applying rewards.
- Decide how you’ll capture recipients’ loyalty signups.
How Orders.co Helps After the Gift Card Is Sold
Your gift card provider handles the card. Whether the promotion pays off depends on what happens after redemption, and that’s where we help.
Our branded direct ordering website gives guests an easy way to order from you again. Our loyalty program lets you set your own points, rewards, and promotions. Automated email and SMS marketing respond to customer behavior, such as reminding a guest who hasn’t ordered in a while. And our customer insights and reporting show who’s coming back and how much of your business comes through direct ordering.
Opa Cafe, a five-person cafe in San Francisco, saw its Orders.co website become its busiest online ordering channel, with 52.8% of its active online orders over the reporting period. Read how Opa Cafe grew direct online orders.
Want a simpler way to turn first-time guests into direct, repeat customers? Book a demo with Orders.co to see how your website, loyalty, marketing, and reporting can work together.
Frequently Asked Questions
Should restaurants offer a discount on gift cards?
A discount is an option, but it’s harder to control. Selling a $50 card for $40 reduces the cash you collect on every card sold. A bonus reward costs you only when a guest redeems it, and it brings that guest back for a visit. If you do discount, limit it to a short window or a set number of cards.
Can a restaurant’s bonus reward expire?
Promotional rewards can generally carry their own expiration date, as long as you disclose it clearly. The money a guest paid for a gift card is different and has federal protections. Print the reward’s start and end dates on the reward itself, not just on your website, and check your state’s rules before you finalize them.
How early should a restaurant start promoting holiday gift cards?
Start before the December rush. A practical plan is to launch around Thanksgiving week and Small Business Saturday, promote steadily through the first three weeks of December, and run a final push for last-minute shoppers in the days before the holidays. Digital cards help most at the end because buyers can send them instantly.
Should restaurants sell physical and digital gift cards?
If your provider supports both, yes. In Toast’s survey, 56% of respondents preferred physical gift cards, 19% preferred digital, and 24% had no preference. For digital cards, email was the most popular delivery method at 39%. Offering both covers buyers who want something to wrap and those who need to send a gift quickly.
What should a restaurant do if a gift-card recipient becomes a regular?
Treat them like any other regular, and remember how they found you. Make sure they’re in your loyalty program, learn their usual order, and include them in your regular email or SMS updates. If you know who bought the original card, thank the buyer. They introduced you to a new customer. Next holiday season, both of them are good people to tell about your gift card offer first.


